Intermittent Fasting vs. One Meal a Day: What's the Difference?

Dr. Dooreck with Evelyn Lee

Jan 185 min read

gi health, nutrition, healthy diet, fasting, gut health, crohn's, ibs, dieting, OMAD

A Brief Overview:

Intermittent fasting (IF) and One Meal a Day (OMAD) are popular eating patterns that have gained significant attention recently, especially on social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram. Both focus on restricting the time window during which you eat, but they have essential differences in how they work. While these trends promise potential benefits for health and weight loss, it's necessary to understand their impact on digestion, metabolism, and overall gut health to pick a pattern that works for your individual needs and goals.

What Is Intermittent Fasting (IF)?

Intermittent fasting refers to a pattern of eating that alternates between periods of eating and fasting. Unlike traditional diets, it doesn't focus on the types of food you eat but on when you eat. The most common intermittent fasting schedules involve fasting for 16 hours and eating within an 8-hour window (known as the 16:8 method). Still, there are multiple variations, too, such as 15:9 or even 20:4.

The most critical aspect of intermittent fasting is the stage of ketosis, or the metabolic state in which the body begins to use fat as its primary energy source. According to Harvard, it generally takes around 12 hours of fasting to enter ketosis, and IF can help you stay in ketosis for longer.

Key Features of Intermittent Fasting (IF):

Fasting Period: This typically lasts 14 to 18 hours. Only non-caloric beverages like water, tea, or black coffee are usually allowed during this period.
Eating Window: You eat all your meals within a set window, such as 8 hours (e.g., from 12 PM to 8 PM).
Flexibility: You can adjust the eating window according to your lifestyle, such as having a longer window on weekends and a shorter one on weekdays.

Benefits for Health:

Inflammation Reduction: IF reduces inflammation and improves inflammation-related diseases like asthma and multiple sclerosis.
Improved Insulin Sensitivity: IF can help lower blood sugar and insulin levels, benefiting those with insulin resistance.
Microbiome Balance: Studies suggest fasting may promote a healthier and more diverse balance of gut bacteria, which can contribute to overall gut health.

Challenges with IF:

Overeating During the Eating Window: Some people may overeat during the eating window, leading to digestive discomfort or bloating. Because IF doesn't necessarily restrict what foods you can have, it's easy to eat unhealthy foods during this time.
Difficulty Adjusting: It may take time to adjust to more extended periods of fasting, especially for beginners or those with a history of digestive issues.

"I hope to add real value to social media and share what my patients ask me about." — Dr. Dooreck

Gut Health ➕ Patient Advocacy with Navigation ➕ Life Balance

If you were looking for information about Private Healthcare Navigation and Patient Advocacy from Executive Health Navigation

Click here for Executive Health Navigation

Having served as doctors for over a decade, we help Family Offices, Private Individuals, Registered Investment Advisors, High-Net-Worth Advisors, and C-Suites navigate the healthcare system for their select clients/families, providing privacy and discretion.

Private Healthcare Navigation and Patient Advocacy when YOU need it most

Executive Health Navigation

What Is One Meal a Day (OMAD)?

As the name suggests, OMAD involves eating just one large meal daily, typically within 1-2 hours. The rest of the day is spent fasting. OMAD is a much more extreme and restrictive form of intermittent fasting.

Key Features of One Meal a Day (OMAD):

Fasting Period: It lasts about 23 hours each day, and only one meal is consumed within a short, 1-2 hour period.
Eating Window: The meal is typically consumed simultaneously, meaning you eat everything in one sitting.
Strict Restriction: There are no snacks or other eating periods throughout the day, making OMAD a more intense form of fasting than intermittent fasting.

Benefits for Health:

Enhanced Digestion: Eating one large meal may allow the digestive system to focus on processing food more efficiently without having multiple meals.
Calorie Control: By limiting food intake to one meal, people may naturally reduce their overall caloric intake, leading to weight loss and improving gut-related inflammation.
Gut Repair: The extended fasting period gives the digestive system extra time to repair itself. Some believe that fasting boosts processes like autophagy (cell repair).

Challenges with OMAD:

Digestive Overload: Eating a large meal simultaneously can overwhelm the digestive system, leading to bloating, indigestion, or discomfort.
Nutrient Deficiency: Getting all the necessary nutrients from one meal can be difficult. OMAD may lead to an imbalance if the meal isn't carefully planned.
Risk of Eating Disorder: Heavily restrictive eating patterns such as OMAD may trigger or worsen existing eating disorders such as bulimia or anorexia nervosa.
Social & Lifestyle Constraints: With such a limited eating window, it may not be sustainable for social events, family meals, or regular work schedules.

Key Differences Between Intermittent Fasting and One Meal a Day

Here's a quick comparison of the two eating patterns:

Feature	Intermittent Fasting (IF)	One Meal a Day (OMAD)
Fasting Period	14-18 hours	23 hours
Eating Window	6-8 hours	1-2 hours
Meals Consumed	Multiple meals within the eating window	One large meal
Flexibility	More flexible, can adjust the eating window	Highly restrictive, eating only once
Potential Benefits	Gut microbiome diversity, improved insulin sensitivity, weight loss	More prolonged ketosis stage, calorie control, weight loss
Challenges	Overeating, adjustment difficulty	Digestive overload, nutrient deficiency, lifestyle constraints

Which One Is Right for You?

Both intermittent fasting and OMAD have their benefits but are unsuitable for everyone. Here are a few considerations when deciding which method might be better for your health:

Choose Intermittent Fasting If:

You want more flexibility with your eating schedule.
You are new to fasting and want to ease into it.
You need more time to digest food between meals.
You want a moderate approach to weight loss and gut health improvement.

Choose One Meal a Day If:

You seek a more intense fasting routine and feel comfortable with fewer meals.
You want to control calorie intake and be able to consume all your nutrients in one meal.
You don't mind or prefer having a shorter eating window and can handle larger meals.

Want to learn more about fasting? Check out this video from TEDxTalks:

Conclusion

While intermittent fasting and OMAD can benefit gut health, weight management, and insulin sensitivity, they both come with challenges that require careful planning. Intermittent fasting is generally more sustainable for most people, offering a flexible approach to improving digestion and metabolism. OMAD, on the other hand, is more restrictive and may work for people seeking a more intense approach but could lead to digestive discomfort or nutritional imbalances if not carefully planned.

Before trying either of these eating patterns, it's essential to listen to your body and, if necessary, consult a healthcare professional, especially if you have any existing digestive concerns.

Personally

I eat a high-fiber, mostly plant-based 🌱 diet, no red meat, drink 4 liters of water a day, exercise, and am focused on keeping nutrition simple. I am sharing what works for me and what I routinely recommend to my patients.

"Balance. Portion control. Keep nutrition simple. Eat Smart. Eat Healthy. 🌱 🌾 🌿"

Gut Health ➕ Patient Advocacy with Navigation ➕ Life Balance

If you were looking for information about Private Healthcare Navigation and Patient Advocacy from Executive Health Navigation

Click here for Executive Health Navigation